Unknown user

     Home

     Login or create username

Statement Map


(tear off copy of map)




All Ratings  | Watch Topic  | Copy Topic  | Ratings Breakdown 
All > Media > Bias  

The MSM whitewash of the discredited Joseph Wilson and the Plamegate affair

Revision History - v1, v2, v3

Published by soc, October 29, 2005, 5:15 pm GMT
Participation: default  
Type: Deductive  
Statements

View
Critiques


1) PREMISE:   
During the State the Union Address on January 28, 2003, President Bush said, "The British Government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa."

none

2) PREMISE:   
Joseph Wilson, in his July 6, 2003 Op-Ed in the New York Times entitled What I Didn't Find In Africa, claimed that he had refuted Bush's claim that Iraq had attempted to purchase uranium from Niger.

2

3) PREMISE:   
According to a bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee Report completed July 7, 2004, Wilson's trip actually lent support to the suggestion that Iraq sought uranium from Niger:
[Former Niger Prime Minister] Mayaki said, however, that in June 1999, [redacted] businessman approached him and insisted that Mayaki meet with an Iraqi delegation to discuss "expanding commercial relations" between Niger and Iraq. The intelligence report said that Mayaki interpreted "expanding commercial relations" to mean that the delegation wanted to discuss uranium yellowcake sales. The intelligence report also said that "although the meeting took place, Mayaki let the matter drop due to the UN sanctions on Iraq."
In a debriefing meeting Ambassador Wilson "did not refute the possibility that Iraq had approached Niger to purchase uranium."

source pdf

1

4) FROM 1,2 AND 3 IT FOLLOWS THAT:   
According to the Washington Post
The panel found that Wilson's report, rather than debunking intelligence about purported uranium sales to Iraq, as he has said, bolstered the case for most intelligence analysts. And contrary to Wilson's assertions and even the government's previous statements, the CIA did not tell the White House it had qualms about the reliability of the Africa intelligence that made its way into 16 fateful words in President Bush's January 2003 State of the Union address.


1

5) PREMISE:   
According to the report, Wilson's wife, Valerie Plame, was the one who suggested him for the trip just as she had recommended him for a previous CIA trip to Niger:
Some CPD [CIA Counterproliferation Division] officials could not recall how the office decided to contact the former ambassador [Wilson], however, interviews and documents provided to the Committee indicate that his wife, a CPD employee, suggested his name for the trip. The CPD reports officer told Committee staff that the former ambassador's wife "offered up his name" and a memorandum to the Deputy Chief of the CPD on February 12, 2002, from the former ambassador's wife says, "my husband has good relations with both the PM [prime minister] and the former Minister of Mines (not to mention lots of French contacts), both of whom could possibly shed light on this sort of activity."

The former ambassador's wife told Committee staff that when CPD decided it would like to send the former ambassador to Niger, she approached her husband on behalf of the CIA and told him "There's this crazy report" on a purported deal for Niger to sell uranium to Iraq.

Analyst's notes indicate that a meeting was "apparently convened by [the former ambassador's] wife who had the idea to dispatch [him] to use his contacts to sort out the Iraq-Niger uranium issue."

The former ambassador had traveled previously to Niger on the CIA's behalf. The former ambassador was selected for the 1999 trip after his wife mentioned to her supervisors that her husband was planning a business trip to Niger in the near future and might be willing to use his contacts in the region.

source pdf

2

6) PREMISE:   
Joseph Wilson stated in his book The Politics of Truth that his wife, "Valerie had nothing to do with the matter." He wrote, "she definitely had not proposed that I make the trip."

1

7) FROM 5 AND 6 IT FOLLOWS THAT:   
The bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee concluded that Wilson's wife was definitely involved in his being selected for his trip to Niger contrary to his denials.

3

8) PREMISE:   
According to the Washington Post Wilson further eroded his credibility with false statements concerning forged documents:
The report also said Wilson provided misleading information to The Washington Post last June. He said then that he concluded the Niger intelligence was based on documents that had clearly been forged because "the dates were wrong and the names were wrong."

"Committee staff asked how the former ambassador could have come to the conclusion that the 'dates were wrong and the names were wrong' when he had never seen the CIA reports and had no knowledge of what names and dates were in the reports," the Senate panel said. Wilson told the panel he may have been confused and may have "misspoken" to reporters. The documents -- purported sales agreements between Niger and Iraq -- were not in U.S. hands until eight months after Wilson made his trip to Niger.

1

9) FROM 4,7 AND 8 IT FOLLOWS THAT:   
According to a bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee Report completed July 7, 2004, Wilson's public statements are contradicted on several substantive points including his fundamental assertion.

[The authors of this report include: Carl Levin (D-MI), Dianne Feinstein (D-CA), Ron Wyden (D-OR), Richard Durbin (D-IL), Evan Bayh (D-IN), John Edwards (D-NC), Barbara Mikulski (D-MD), Orrin Hatch (R-UT), Mike DeWine (R-OH), Christopher Bond (R-MO), Trent Lott (R-MS), Olympia Snowe (R-ME), Chuck Hagel (R-NE), Saxby Chambliss (R-GE), John Warner (R-VA)]

none

10) PREMISE:   
On July 27th, the New York Times repeated Wilson's claims again without revealing the whole truth which is that his statements have since been discredited in a bipartisan fashion:
After traveling to Africa in 2002 on a C.I.A.-sponsored mission to look into claims that Iraq had sought to acquire material there for its nuclear weapons program, Mr. Wilson wrote in an Op-Ed article in The New York Times on July 6, 2003, that the White House had "twisted" the intelligence regarding the suspected transaction to justify the invasion of Iraq.

none

11) PREMISE:   
On July 27th, CNN wrote about Wilson's assertions as if they were undisputed facts:
The July 2003 article cast doubt on a key assertion in the Bush administration's arguments for war with Iraq -- that Iraq had sought to purchase uranium in Africa for a suspected nuclear weapons program.

Wilson, who was acting ambassador to Iraq before the 1991 Persian Gulf War, said the CIA sent him to Niger, in central Africa, to investigate the uranium claim in February 2002 and that he found no evidence such a transaction occurred and it was unlikely it could have.

1

12) PREMISE:   
MSNBC reported (via AP) about Wilson without any reference to his contradictions: "Plame’s husband went to the country on the CIA’s behalf to check into the claim and reported he could not substantiate it."

1

13) PREMISE:   
On July 27th Reuters also simply repeats Wilson's assertions:
Plame's identity was leaked to the media after her diplomat husband, Joseph Wilson, accused the Bush administration of twisting prewar intelligence to support military action against Iraq. Wilson said it was done deliberately to erode his credibility.

1

14) FROM 9,10,11,12 AND 13 IT FOLLOWS THAT:   
The mainstream media (MSM) continually repeats Wilson's false assertions without reporting the entire truth in an attempt to make him appear more credible than he is.

[Which is not to say that the independent investigation is flawed concerning other issues/crimes but only that Wilson truly has no credibility on this issue.]

1

Overall Topic Rating:

As I have not agreed with any critiques:

I find this topic to be sound




All Ratings  | Watch Topic  | Copy Topic  | Ratings Breakdown 




Other Topics by this Author


Title Published
Katrina & Political Malfeasance: A Collaboration
Politics
Sep 14, 2005
Determinism is false
Philosophy > Determinism
Aug 20, 2005
Roe v. Wade is Unconstitutional
Social Issues >Abortion > Pro-life
Jul 28, 2005
The Implicatons of Free-Will
Philosophy > Free-Will
Apr 30, 2005




About This Site  -  FAQ  -  Contact Us