Unknown user

     Home

     Login or create username

Statement Map


(tear off copy of map)



All Ratings  | Watch Topic  | Copy Topic  | Ratings Breakdown 
All > Social Issues  

Sweatshops and child labor are not bad

Revision History - v1

Published by DanielLC, December 26, 2009, 5:30 pm GMT
Participation: default  
Type: Deductive  
Statements

View
Critiques


1) PREMISE:   
In third-world countries, people are poor because of their circumstances.

1

2) FROM 1 IT FOLLOWS THAT:   
In third-world countries, people are not poor due to lack of intelligence.

1

3) FROM 2 IT FOLLOWS THAT:   
Poor people in third-world countries are not stupid.

none

4) PREMISE:   
In third-world countries, most people will work in sweatshops if they pay well for jobs in the area, and will choose to have their children work when it's an option.

1

5) FROM 3 AND 4 IT FOLLOWS THAT:   
In third-world countries, the existence of sweatshops and child labor is a good thing.

none
Overall Topic Rating:

 As I have not agreed with any critiques:

I find this topic to be sound



All Ratings  | Watch Topic  | Copy Topic  | Ratings Breakdown 




Other Topics by this Author


Title Published
Infinite Afterlife is Infinitely Improbable
Philosophy > Atheism 		Sep 5, 2010
Utilitarianism from Selfishness
Philosophy >Ethics > Meta-ethics 		Aug 12, 2010
Euthanasia probably can be good.
Social Issues > Euthanasia 		Apr 14, 2010
Utilitarianism is at least partially true.
Philosophy >Ethics > Normative Ethics 		Mar 31, 2010
Politicians are smarter and more concerned about your future than you are.
Politics > Economics 		Mar 28, 2010
Time reversibility of morality
Social Issues >Abortion > Pro-choice 		Mar 28, 2010
You have put a dollar value on human life.
Philosophy > Humanism 		Mar 28, 2010
Illegalizing the organ trade is murder
Social Issues 		Feb 13, 2010
The organ trade should be legalized.
Social Issues 		Jan 10, 2010
It's reasonable to assume Presentism is false.
Philosophy 		Dec 22, 2009
Abortion might be murder
Social Issues >Abortion > Pro-life 		Dec 21, 2009
Doomsday Argument (simple version)
Philosophy 		Dec 4, 2009
Military draft is always a bad idea.
Politics 		Nov 14, 2009
The is-ought problem is unsolvable.
Philosophy >Ethics > Meta-ethics 		Nov 3, 2009
Mere Addition Paradox
Philosophy >Ethics > Normative Ethics 		Nov 1, 2009
Ethics are, in all likelihood, counterintuitive.
Philosophy >Ethics > Meta-ethics 		Nov 1, 2009
Deontology is inherently selfish.
Philosophy >Ethics > Normative Ethics 		Oct 21, 2009
Absurd Consequences of Moral Relativism
Philosophy >Ethics > Meta-ethics 		Sep 2, 2009
Doomsday Argument
Philosophy 		Aug 25, 2009
Falsifiability is not necessary
Science > Science Theory 		Aug 23, 2009
Rights of Victims of Domestic Abuse Negative II
Law > Criminal 		Aug 22, 2009
Santa Claus is real II
Philosophy > Paradoxes 		Aug 21, 2009
Government intervention is not necessary to end a recession. Short version.
Politics > Economics 		Aug 21, 2009
Government intervention is not necessary to end a recession.
Politics > Economics 		Aug 21, 2009
The best action is the one with the best consequences.
Philosophy >Ethics > Normative Ethics 		Aug 21, 2009
Being a nihilist is neutral at best.
Philosophy >Ethics > Meta-ethics 		Aug 21, 2009
Charities should be judged by their effectiveness
Philosophy > Ethics 		Aug 21, 2009



About This Site  -  FAQ  -  Contact Us